← All work
00
UX audit · 2024

Heuristic Evaluation

Turning a leaky homepage into a prioritized backlog.

19usability issues logged
4heuristics violated
17competitors benchmarked

A UX audit of the Xgrid homepage using Nielsen’s heuristics and a competitive analysis, then triaged by severity and effort into a backlog the team could ship.

Role
UX Lead, Xgrid
Timeline
1 week
Method
Heuristic evaluation + competitive analysis
Team
With Hammad RiazResearch with Wisha and Sammra
Heuristics analysis · Home page
Findings annotated on the Xgrid homepage navigation
01The problem

The homepage was a leaky bucket.

The Xgrid homepage is the primary engine for B2B lead generation, but navigational friction, accessibility gaps and a confusing visual hierarchy were leaking visitors before they reached the lead form.

02Goal & approach

From opinions to a structured audit.

The goal was to move from subjective opinions to a structured, repeatable audit. I evaluated every homepage section against Nielsen’s heuristics, benchmarked competitors, then triaged each finding by severity and ease of fix.

Step 1

Heuristic evaluation

Every section checked against Nielsen’s heuristics.

Step 2

Competitive analysis

A matrix of 17 competitors across 4 comparison tracks.

Step 3

Severity × effort

Severity S0–S4 and ease-to-fix E0–E4 for every issue.

Step 4

Prioritized backlog

High, medium and low, ready for the team.

Heuristics analysis matrix: severity S0 to S4, ease to fix E0 to E4, heuristics violated, and every issue with a suggestion and priority
TriageThe audit matrix: every issue scored for severity and ease of fix, with a suggestion and a priority

I ran this audit as UX Lead at Xgrid. More from that time: Xgrid.co Revamp · Alkira · Project X

03By the numbers

One week, one clear picture.

19

Usability issues logged

4

Heuristics violated

2

High-priority quick wins

17

Competitors benchmarked

Every homepage section reviewed4 comparison tracks
04Findings

In enterprise B2B, a confused user is a lost lead.

Core navigation (the hamburger icon and a missing Home state) was breaking the basic heuristic of mapping between the system and the real world. Primary brand color on non-interactive text made it look clickable, so visitors tried to click it.

Heuristics analysis · Navigation
Findings 1.1 to 1.3 annotated on the navigation

Findings 1.1–1.3, annotated directly on the navigation area of the live homepage.

Heuristics violated

H2 · MappingH3 · Freedom & controlH4 · ConsistencyH8 · Aesthetic & minimal

Ambiguous menu icon

The hamburger reads as decorative rather than a menu trigger, with no visual cue that distinguishes it from graphics.

No way back to Home

From an interior page, neither the logo nor the nav offers a Home state: a basic wayfinding failure.

Primary color used as emphasis

Brand-color text appears on non-clickable copy in three places, reading as a broken link.

Inaccessible carousels

Testimonial and badge carousels lack discoverable controls, hiding content the user never gets back to.

Section-by-section audit of the homepage with findings next to each section
Section by sectionNavigation, hero, why us, achievements, certifications and testimonials, each with its findings. Scroll inside the frame.
05Competitive analysis

17 products, patterns worth adopting.

11 of the 17 products benchmarked contributed at least one adoptable pattern.

Competitive analysis matrix: top competitors, look and feel, and features by section
Matrix17 competitors compared on look and feel, typography and features by section
Excerpts: design style and typography benchmarking, and features to adopt per competitor
DistilledFrom benchmarking notes to features worth adopting

Patterns adopted from

IDEOLollypopEleksOrizonUnbounceMcKinseyAddison WhitneyNetguruVirtusaAccentureEPAM

Competitor research by Muhammad Maavia, Hammad Riaz, Wisha and Sammra.

06Output

From audit to prioritized backlog.

Every finding carries a priority tag derived directly from its Severity × Effort score.

2

High priority · ship now

11%
5

Medium · next sprint

26%
12

Low · backlog

63%
High · ship now

1.2 Direct link inconsistency

Some nav items expand, others link directly, with no visual distinction. S3 · E1

1.3 Home state missing

No path back to the homepage from an interior page. S3 · E1

Medium · next sprint
  • 2.1 Hero headline lacks context
  • 3.1 Key info hidden behind a wait state
  • 3.4 Achievement cards read as static
  • 5.3 Testimonial nav needs prominence
  • 7.1 Case studies unreadable in place
Low · backlog

12 cosmetic & consistency items

Primary-color text used as plain emphasis, inconsistent CTA styling, minor decorative obstacles and carousel-badge visibility.

07The full audit

Page by page, section by section.

Xgrid · Homepage UX audit
Full Xgrid homepage UX audit case study

Scroll inside the frame to see the full page.

08Retrospective

What I’d do differently.

01

Pair severity scores with real behavioral data (heatmaps, funnel drop-off) before finalizing priority. Right now severity is expert judgment, not measured behavior.

02

Loop in an engineer earlier to sanity-check Ease-to-Fix scores. Effort estimates are still a designer’s guess until dev weighs in.

03

Ship the two quick wins, then re-test the wayfinding tasks with real users to close the audit → validation loop.

04

Turn this into a repeatable audit template, so the next client pitch doesn’t start from zero.

“This is the method I would reuse when auditing a client’s product before a pitch.”

That’s a wrap

Thanks for reading.

See the original case study on Behance.

Co-owned with Hammad Riaz on Behance.

Did you like it?

Leave a like

A quick human check keeps likes honest. One like per visitor.

0 views0 likes